Linked by Thom Holwerda on Fri 8th Sep 2006 20:51 UTC
Linspire Linux.com reviews the Koobox Linspire-based mini-PC, and concludes: "If you want a mini-PC form factor that's Linux-compatible, the Mini Koobox seems to be one of the best values on the market. It's small and quiet, and its performance is fine for normal desktop use. I might recommend ditching Linspire and installing a different distro once it's in your hands, but if small is your thing, I'd recommend picking up a Mini."
Order by: Score:
It is very curious
by alcibiades on Fri 8th Sep 2006 21:10 UTC
alcibiades
Member since:
2005-10-12

It is very curious how much the Mini lookalikes cost, at least in the UK. Look at the Evesham versions, and they are more than Apple's version. Look at the Aopen barebones versions, and if you equip them you will pay more than the Apple version. The barebones is north of 300 sterling. And yet why should an Aopen Mini barebones cost 5 times the iWill barebones? Is there any reason it should cost two or three times a Shuttle?

Anyone have any ideas what is going on?

RE: It is very curious
by Morty on Fri 8th Sep 2006 22:09 UTC in reply to "It is very curious"
Morty Member since:
2005-07-06

Is there any reason it should cost two or three times a Shuttle?

The word is commodity hardware. Afterall a Shuttle uses a industry standard motherboard avaliable from most vendors, and they are sold in high numbers. Giving you the two most important factors when it comes to cost of computer equipment, competition and high volume.

None of the Mini lookalikes comes anywhere near in units shipped to shuttles. And they don't follow a standard form factors etc, making them non interchangeable.

While Apple's are produced in much higher volumes, giving them the benefit of cost savings due to high volume.

RE[2]: It is very curious
by AdamW on Fri 8th Sep 2006 22:15 UTC in reply to "RE: It is very curious"
AdamW Member since:
2005-07-06

Shuttles don't use a very common motherboard form factor. I don't know anyone besides Shuttle themselves who make Shuttle-size motherboards.

RE[3]: It is very curious
by jaylaa on Sat 9th Sep 2006 01:27 UTC in reply to "RE: It is very curious"
jaylaa Member since:
2006-01-17

To follow up on the 'commodity hardware' theme, Shuttles (at least the ones I have) use desktop sized hard drives, optical drives, and desktop cpus. Whereas these minis have laptop drives, laptop cpus (I think) and fancy super-thin optical drives.

So yeah, they should be cheaper.

Why?
by kwanbis on Fri 8th Sep 2006 22:07 UTC
kwanbis
Member since:
2005-07-06

Why would i buy this thing for 400 u$s (actually 500 minus 100 rebate), when i can have, for example, a
Dell Dimension 1100 Celeron D 2.53GHz Desktop with the Dell E196FP 19" LCD Monitor, 256MB RAM, 80GB hard drive, DVD-ROM drive for $369 (+$29.99 for shipping)? Only cause it looks small?

NOTE: i have to add a 19LCD to the koobox.

Edited 2006-09-08 22:08

RE: Why?
by diskinetic on Fri 8th Sep 2006 22:41 UTC in reply to "Why?"
diskinetic Member since:
2005-12-09

"Only cause it looks small?"

Yup.

There are those among us who prefer some amount of prettiness, even at the cost of performance and hard-earned cash. I saw an article in (I believe) Motor Trend that compared the EVO VIII to a Porsche Cayman S. It was a "technical" tie, but the enthusiast nod went to the Porsche because of sexiness and air of exclusivity, even though the Porsche was almost twice as expensive. You have a valid and persuasive point, but it is lost in the eyes of love.

Edited 2006-09-08 22:42

RE: Why?
by alcibiades on Sat 9th Sep 2006 07:15 UTC in reply to "Why?"
alcibiades Member since:
2005-10-12

Yes, you can make a similar point about the Apple version.

By the way, the Aopen version seems to have desktop hard drives, so that can't be the explanation.

Looks familiar
by diskinetic on Fri 8th Sep 2006 22:36 UTC
diskinetic
Member since:
2005-12-09

It's also one of the exact same boxes used by system76 for Ubuntu hosting. Not a slam or anything, just an observation.

uh
by deanlinkous on Sat 9th Sep 2006 04:19 UTC
deanlinkous
Member since:
2006-06-19

no comment ;)

oh ok
by deanlinkous on Sat 9th Sep 2006 05:12 UTC
deanlinkous
Member since:
2006-06-19

"Of course, the pricing is shown with the rebate already applied on the Koobox site, which is a bit deceptive."

deceptive? surely you jest...

2c
by transputer_guy on Sat 9th Sep 2006 08:34 UTC
transputer_guy
Member since:
2005-07-08

Quite tempting, although I'd probably flip the OS to something else, wonder if it does BeOS, Ubantu.

The Mini is $100 (after rebate) more than the similar spec more traditional Essential model, that kind of difference is pretty tiny to get into this small form factor.

Try building any type of Mini PC, its almost impossible, you really have to go with miniITX to get something that is still twics as big as these koobox puppies.

Its not just size, noise is an even bigger issue.
Also 2.5" HDs will be 3x the price of 3.5" HDs for same capacity but are usually totally silent from 1m.

It may make more sense to use Apple minis with alt OSes to get the volume discounts but then deal with their loader. The koobox with better processor, ram, HD gets too close to Apple mini prices but choice is good.

Nice but...
by Jedd on Sat 9th Sep 2006 20:50 UTC
Jedd
Member since:
2005-07-06

... I'd remove Linspire and put SlackWare on it. :-p

All kidding aside here is a great Mini system:

http://www.damnsmalllinux.org/store/Mini_ITX_Systems/M10000_Hard_Dr...

well worth the money. ;)

An there is always....
by fithisux on Sun 10th Sep 2006 10:26 UTC
fithisux
Member since:
2006-01-22
DoctorPepper
Member since:
2005-07-12

The $100 rebate is nice, if you want the bare system. If you want more memory and/or a larger hard drive, you have to pay quite a lot more.

Why should I do that when I can get a Mac mini for $599, with a 1.66 GHz Core-Duo processor, 512 MB of RAM and a 60 GB hard drive? Sure, it runs OSX, but I can run Linux on it too, if I want.

HP Slimline s7520n
by Fatal Claws on Sun 10th Sep 2006 20:40 UTC
Fatal Claws
Member since:
2006-09-10

Here is another possible alternative. It is a desktop machine, but has a very small size - 9.75 x 4.375 x 13.125 (HxWxD). When using the machine at Staples, I could not hear any noise coming from it. The vertically mounted DVD/CD drive is a LightScribe multi-format DVD/CD burner with dual-layer support which opens/closes with the push of a button.

Not bad for $550.

http://tinyurl.com/prz4t

Edited 2006-09-10 20:44